Home > Our Deli > Cheeses Online
Sort By:
Page of 1
Amish Butter Cheese 8 oz Amish Butter Cheese 8 oz

Our Amish Butter Cheese in an 8 oz piece. This cheese is mild but has a nice buttery flavor. Perfect for melting, crackers, and wine pairings.

Price: $4.59
Baby Swiss 12 oz Baby Swiss 12 oz

Our Baby Swiss cheese in a 12 oz wedge. This is one of the creamiest Swiss cheeses you can find! Tiny holes, lots of flavor!

Price: $5.39
Baby Swiss 2 pound Baby Swiss 2 pound

Our Baby Swiss cheese in a 2 pound wheel. This is one of the creamiest Swiss cheeses you can find! Tiny holes, lots of flavor! Great for gifts!

Price: $14.99
Baby Swiss 5 pound Baby Swiss 5 pound

Our Baby Swiss cheese in a 5 pound wheel. This is one of the creamiest Swiss cheeses you can find! Tiny holes, lots of flavor! Great for gifts!

Price: $24.95
Bacon Cheese 8 oz Bacon Cheese 8 oz

Our Bacon cheese in an 8 oz piece. This cheese has whole bits of bacon throughout it, what's not to love!

Price: $3.29
Colby 8 oz Colby 8 oz

Our Longhorn/Colby Cheese in a prepackaged half pound piece.

Price: $3.29
Garlic Cheddar 8 oz Garlic Cheddar 8 oz

Our Garlic Cheddar cheese in an 8 oz piece. This cheese has a strong garlic flavor, made especially for those who love garlic!

Price: $4.99
Ghost Pepper Jack 12 oz Ghost Pepper Jack 12 oz

Our Ghost Pepper Jack cheese in an 8 oz package. Made with Ghost peppers, this cheese is sure to light a fire in your mouth! Be careful eating this one, as it is one of the hottest cheeses currently on the market!

*Not intended for Children, pets, or anyone who can't handle the heat!

*Avoid Contact with eyes

Price: $7.95
Havarti 8 oz Havarti 8 oz

Our Havarti Cheese in an 8 oz piece. Creamy, smooth, mild, flavorful cheese. Perfect for snacking with crackers, pairs well with wines.

Price: $4.59
Hot Pepper 14 oz Hot Pepper 14 oz

Our Hot Pepper Cheese in a 14 oz piece. This is a hot cheese made with JalapeƱos and Red peppers. On the hotness scale, this one falls right in the middle, between Pepper Jack (Mild) and Ghost Pepper (Hottest).

Price: $4.99
Marble 8 oz Marble 8 oz

Our Marble Cheese, Colby and Monterey Jack, in a prepackaged half pound piece.

Price: $3.29
Mozzarella 8 oz Mozzarella 8 oz

Our Mozzarella Cheese, in an 8 oz piece.  This cheese is perfect shredded on pizza! Made with part skim milk.

Price: $3.59
Muenster 8 oz Muenster 8 oz

Our Muenster Cheese in an 8 oz piece.  Smooth, creamy, and mild cheese.  Perfect for cheese and crackers, wine tastings, and sandwiches.

Price: $3.29
Pepper Jack 8 oz Pepper Jack 8 oz

Our Pepper Jack Cheese in an 8 oz piece.  This is the mildest of our pepper cheeses, made with a Monterey Jack base.

Price: $3.29
Pepperoni Cheese 12 oz Pepperoni Cheese 12 oz

Our Pepperoni cheese in a 12 oz piece. This cheese is one of our more popular cheeses, and has pepperoni throughout it! Yummy!



Price: $4.59
Sharp Cheddar 12 oz Sharp Cheddar 12 oz

Our Sharp Cheddar (white) in a 12 oz piece. This is our most popular cheese, perfect for everything cheese related! Grilled Cheese, Macaroni and Cheese, Crackers, Sandwiches, Dips, snacking, wine tasting, just about everything you can imagine!

Price: $6.99
Smoked Cheddar 12 oz Smoked Cheddar 12 oz

Our Smoked Cheddar cheese (orange) in a 12 oz piece.  This cheese has a wonderful flavor from the cheese, along with a great hickory smoke taste.

Price: $5.99
Smoked Swiss 8 oz Smoked Swiss 8 oz

Our Smoked Swiss cheese in an 8 oz piece. This cheese has a creamy texture and wonderful hickory smoke flavor.

Price: $3.59
Swiss 12 oz Swiss 12 oz

Our Swiss cheese in a 12 oz piece.  Melts very well!

Price: $5.99